Criminal Defence Solicitor

Criminal Defence Solicitor

Criminal Defence Solicitor

Against a charge of murder in an English court, a defendant may raise a partial defence of provocation. The Oxford Dictionary of Law (fifth edition) summarises this defence as: “Conduct or words causing someone to lose his self-control”. The loss of self-control must be at the time the defendant goes on to kill, and the provocation itself must be of such a nature than a “reasonable person” would likely have acted in the same manner.

If successful, provocation will reduce the crime for which the defendant is liable to manslaughter; which carries a far lower sentence. It cannot, however, ever fully discharge liability to the extent that a defendant will walk free.

Who Can Provoke?

Although in general, provocation will have come from the victim and it will be aimed at the defendant, this need not always be the case. In R v. Davies [1975], the court held that it is possible for a third party to cause the provocation, while R v. Pearson [1992] states that provocation can be aimed at a third party. The vital point is therefore that provocation is words or conduct that cause a loss of self-control in the defendant, regardless of their origin or who, if anyone, they were directed at.